Case for, or Against

In: Business and Management

Submitted By swinfordp
Words 575
Pages 3
Assignment 2: LASA 2—The Case For, or Against, New Orleans
Sometimes one’s choices may involve catastrophic decisions and bear great risk and yet there can be no clear answer. For example, if a person gets a divorce, shutters a plant, sells a losing investment, or closes their business, will he or she be better off? The following case incorporates nearly all of the material you have covered this far and presents an example of one such choice where nearly all of the alternatives have a significant downside risk.
Review the following information from the article “A Cost-Benefit Analysis of the New Orleans Flood Protection System” by Stéphane Hallegatte (2005):
• Hallegatte, an environmentalist, assigns a probability (p) of a Katrina-like hurricane of 1/130 in his cost-benefit analysis for flood protection. However, the levees that protect New Orleans also put other regions at greater risk. You may assume the frequency of other floods is greater than Katrina-like events (Vastag & Rein, 2011).
• The new levees that were built in response to Katrina cost approximately fourteen billion dollars (in 2010). This is in addition to the direct costs of Katrina (eighty-one billion dollars in 2005).
• 50 percent of New Orleans is at or below sea level.
• A 100-year event means that there is a 63 percent chance that such an event will occur within a 100-year period.
• The following are the interested (anchored and/or biased) constituencies: o Residents of New Orleans—both those that can move and those who cannot move o Residents of the surrounding floodplains at risk from New Orleans levees o The Mayor of New Orleans o The federal government—specifically taxpayers and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
Assume that the availability heuristics makes people more risk averse (populations drop, at least in the short term). Consider how this would affect the…...

Similar Documents

The Case for, or Against, New Orleans

...understand the impact of risks on the business, and provide other options for risk mitigation. Maintenance of the risk register on a regular basis is essential to an organization. It must be reviewed, updated and validated consistently. When risks are "closed," they should be destroyed and removed. If they only use the register to add new risk it will quickly become bloated and be just another irrelevant reference document that will not even be able to be used. Mandatory elements that the new risk register will record Description of the risk from a business perspective: When defining the risk, security organizations must think about how the description will be received by the business. Will it follow, or will it be perceived as another case of security blowing risks out of proportion? Relevant entity: A description of the business entity that will be impacted by the risk is crucial to making the right risk treatment decisions. The entity can be a process, a system or technology platform. This section should also include information about the owners of the asset that is threatened by the risk. It is fairly common for the entity owner to be different than the owner of the risk, and the risk register is where this should be documented. Criticality or importance of the entity: Stress (the importance) should be used as a modifier Practical examples of risk impacts: Provide real, relevant examples of the type of impact that would come to realization if the risk were......

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

Make Out a Case Against the Adoption of Codified Constitution for the Uk

...Make out a case against the adoption of codified constitution for the UK A constitution is a system of rules which describes the structure and powers of the government, the relationship between different parts of government and the relationship between government and citizens. The UK has a un-codified constitution which means it is not written out in one single document. Unlike codified constitutions which are, such as the US constitution. There are many arguments against the idea of a codified constitution. One argument is that codified constitutions are considered inflexible, because higher law is more difficult to change than statute law. It’s easier to introduce an act of parliament than to amend a constitution. The UKs constitution is flexible as it is not entrenched. This is good because the constitution stays relevant and up to date. For codified constitutions it is difficult to change and adapt so this is a downside. A second argument against agreeing to a codified constitution is that parliamentary sovereignty would be effectively ended. The principle of parliamentary sovereignty states that parliament can make unmake or amend any law it wishes. With a codified constitution parliament would not be able to make, unmake or amend any law it wishes due to the existence of the constitution. This is because a codified constitution would act as higher law. Another point is that a new codified constitution in the UK is unnecessary. Codified constitutions may also not be...

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Application Case 16.1 the Case for and Against Drug Testing

...not to have a drug-testing policy in corporate America is a major undertaking. Alcohol and drug abuse are considered to be amongst the most common and dangerous health hazards in the workplace. Drug use in the workplace is an increased liability to employers and can cost companies millions of dollars in legal expenses and compliance standards. In this case study, Castulon Corporation, is faced with a dilemma of whether or not to implement a drug-testing policy. The cause for this dilemma is the fact that upper management has been notified of two separate incidents in the past two months of possible drug abuse (Ivancevich p. 532). In this case study, it would seem logical that Castulon Coporation should establish a drug-testing program. Where it is legal to do so nearly every company or business should have a drug-testing policy. The policy does not have to be mandatory for all situations, but should at least be a requirement after a significant mistake or accident. There are many pros and cons to utilizing a drug-testing program but the biggest positive out ways everything which is safety. This is especially true for this case study as the company is in the manufacturing industry so they are at a higher risk for injury and loss of life (Ivancevich p. 533). A drug-testing policy would start with screening any newly hired employees. This would be a pre-condition of employment. The individual would have to pass an initial drug test. This pre-employment drug testing gives......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

The Case for and Against Buffer Stocks

...Evaluate the case for and against using a buffer stock scheme to stabilise the price of a commodity such as sugar or tin. A buffer stock scheme is an intervention carried out by the government which aims to limit fluctuations in the price of a commodity. But is it the best way to stabilise the price of a commodity like sugar or tin? Consider what would happen if there was no intervention in a commodity market, such as sugar: In the diagram, the Supply for Year 1 is S, which gives a Price of P and Quantity of Q. This is deemed by the government to provide a price which is fair to both consumers and producers and an adequate supply of the commodity. In Year 2 there is a bumper harvest (shown as S2 on the diagram). Without a buffer stock system then price will fall to P2 and Quantity rises to Q2. This could present a problem to producers, who may consider P2 is too low a price for their commodity. In Year 3 there is a poor harvest (shown as S3 on the diagram). Without a buffer stock system then price will rise to P3 and Quantity fall to Q3. Also, P3 could be deemed an unfair price for consumers to pay by the government. The buffer stock system works by minimising fluctuations in the supply of a commodity to help to stabilise price. When there is a good harvest, the government can choose to buy and store the excess supply (Q-Q2). This will keep the price at P and Quantity at Q. However, if there is a bad harvest, the excess commodity from Year 2 can be used to boost......

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Economic Case Against Monopoly

...The economic case against monopoly * A profit-maximising firm will produce at the productively and allocatively efficient level of output in a perfectly competitive industry * The conventional argument against market power is that monopolists can earn abnormal (supernormal) profits at the expense of efficiency and the welfare of consumers and society. * The monopoly price is assumed to be higher than both marginal and average costs leading to a loss of allocative efficiency and a failure of the market. The monopolist is extracting a price from consumers that is above the cost of resources used in making the product and, consumers’ needs and wants are not being satisfied, as the product is being under-consumed. * The higher average cost if there are inefficiencies in production means that the firm is not making optimum use of scarce resources. Under these conditions, there may be a case for government intervention for example through competition policy or market deregulation. Potential Benefits from Monopoly A high market concentration does not always signal the absence of competition; sometimes it can reflect the success of firms in providing better-quality products, more efficiently, than their rivals One difficulty in assessing the welfare consequences of monopoly, duopoly or oligopoly lies in defining precisely what a market constitutes! In nearly every industry a market is segmented into different products, and globalization makes it difficult to......

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Evaluate the Case for and Against the Nhs Charging for Its Services

...Evaluate the case for and against the NHS charging for its services The National Health Service was first launched in 1948 and has grown to become the world’s largest publicly funded health service. It helps people’s health for everything from antenatal screening and routine treatments for long term conditions, to transplant, emergency treatment and end-of-life care. Out of the healthcare systems for Australia, Canada, Germany, Netherlands, New Zealand and USA, the NHS was rated as the best system in terms of efficiency, cost related problems and effective care. It was also ranked the second for patient equality and safety. In 1948 when the NHS was first launched it had a budget of £437 million, now in 2013 its budget is around £108.9 billion. It is funded directly by taxation. The NHS is free to the public but it is struggling to afford the public health needs. This is similar to the Central economic problem that there are scarce resources but humans have infinite wants and needs. The NHS is similar because it has a certain amount of money but humans constantly need healthcare. The NHS cannot keep up with the public’s need and therefore there are arguments that the NHS should charge for their service. Opportunity cost is the loss of potential gain from other alternatives when one alternative is chosen. The National Health Service has begun denying patients cataract operations and hip replacements because it is struggling to stay within its budget. This is an......

Words: 798 - Pages: 4

The Case for and Against Drugs

...The Case for and Against Drug Testing Case Study 16-1 Columbia Southern University The adversity that the Castulon Corporation is faced with during the recent discovery of employee’s use of drugs on and off the facility, they’re trying to decide what can be done about the current situation while implementing a drug screening policy to resolve the situation. According Drug Use Statistics, “Among unemployed adults aged 18 or older in 2009, 17.0 percent were current illicit drug users, which were higher than the 8.0 percent of those employed full time and 11.5 percent of those employed part time. However, most illicit drug users were employed. Of the 19.3 million current illicit drug users aged 18 or older in 2009, 12.9 million (66.6 percent) were employed either full or part time” (Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration, 2010). Not to mention prescription drug abuse or alcohol abuse. Some say those statistics and Castulon Corporation’s current issues that the implementation of a drug screening policy should not should be put in place immediately. However, what implications would it have on the employees who are not a using drugs, and how far should the testing go, after all alcohol and prescription drug use can cause just as much damage. The one thing Castulon did was weigh the pros and cons, and assigned the task to two employees of proving both sides to management. I do agree that there are some industries where drug screening should be......

Words: 947 - Pages: 4

Cases Where Moving and Storage Companies Were Sued for Some Type of Fraud Against the Consumer and/or Against Other Businesses

...PART I – 5 Cases where moving and storage companies were sued for some type of fraud against the Consumer and/or against other Businesses These group of cases represent consumers in lawsuits against moving companies and/or arbitration. Lawsuits against moving companies may include damages to property, breach of contract, tariff or regulatory violations, and hostage loads. * The Attorney General's Office filed a lawsuit against Moving Max in July 2014, alleging they "engaged in a predatory bait and switch scheme," billed customers for "bogus charges," and then "threatened to drive off and retain the customers personal belongings unless and until payment was made by cash or money order." Under the terms of the Final Consent Judgment (entered February 13, 2015), that concluded a lawsuit filed in State Superior Court in Bergen County, the owner of Moving Max, Inc., a moving and storage company based in Fair Lawn, and the owner’s father, are permanently barred from owning or working in such businesses in New Jersey. In addition, as part of the settlement, 18 consumers who complained that their possessions were held until they paid substantially higher moving costs than agreed to, will be reimbursed for their losses. Case Cite: John J. Hoffman v. Moving Max, Inc., et al. Bergen County New Jersey Case No.: BER-C-203-14 * Shurgard Storage Centers, Inc. (plaintiff) and Safeguard Self Storage, Inc.......

Words: 982 - Pages: 4

The Case Against Quickspeak

...the article easy to read and follow. In paragraph 4, there are transitions that helps reader in assuming about what he/she is going to read or what writer is talking about. For example, transitions like many, without, now, at least have been used which helps in guiding the reader about reading and help them in assuming the purpose of reading. Moreover, examples in a sentence form also been used like there’s meeting in week at 9 but what 9? A.m. or p.m.? Meeting purpose? All these things are not mentioned clearly because of quickspeak. Yes, they are effective as it gives a break to a sentence. What is more, these transitions helps in giving a perfect beginning to the sentence. For an instance, transition like “many” describes the number of cases writer’s talking about. “Without” explains that what is incomplete in the above sentences. “Now” explains about the time period and “at least” describes the length of the messages. All these transitions are very effective because they made the short length of paragraph and also made them complex that helps reader in understanding the article....

Words: 644 - Pages: 3

Case Against Quick Speak

...7–0.8) on dried foods. Spores tolerate harsh environment conditions but most are sensitive to the heat treatment. An exception is Byssochlammys, whose spores have a D value of 1–12 minutes at 90ºC. Different mold species have different optimal growth temperatures, with some able to grow in refrigerators. They have wide secondary metabolism producing a number of toxic and carcinogenic mycotoxins. Aspergillus and related molds generally grow faster and are more resistant to high temperatures and low water activity than Penicillium spp. and spoil foods in warmer climates. (Rawat, 2015). FOOD SPOILAGE BY INSECTS, PARASITES AND RODENTS Foods in cans, jars, cartons, plastics or paper are to ensure food safety because it provides protection against entry of microorganisms, dust, dirt, insects, chemicals and foreign material, etc. Parasites also live in beef, poultry, pork, seafood, animal, human feces, and contaminated water cause food-borne illnesses, as refrigeration doesn’t kill parasites. Anisakis simplex is a parasite found in contaminated raw and undercooked fish and seafood. (Jacqueline and Gutierrez, 2013). FIGURE:- Example of opened food product which is infected by insects. FOOD SPOILAGE BY TEMPERATURE The biggest factor of bacterial growth for perishable food is temperature. Spore-forming bacteria are mostly associated with spoilage of heat-treated foods as their spores survive high processing temperatures. Some thermophiles (Bacillus and Geobacillus spp.) cause......

Words: 2878 - Pages: 12

Executive Summary of the Case Against the Tobacco Industry

...Contents Key Players 2 Prosecution 2 Defense 2 The Case 2 Available Statistics 3 Political Spending 3 Prior Litigation 3 The Strategy 4 Liggett Breaks Away 4 First Round of Talks 5 First Round Negotiations 6 Problem Assessment after First Round of Negotiations 6 Solutions 6 Second Round of Talks 7 Second Round Negotiations 7 Problems during the Second Round of Negotiations 7 Third Round of Talks 8 Resolution of Issues 8 The Settlement 8 Key Players Prosecution 1. Mike Moore, Attorney General Mississippi 2. Bob Butterworth, Attorney General Florida 3. Dickie Scruggs, Plaintiff Lawyer 4. Scott Harshbarger, Attorney General Massachusetts Defense 1. Steven Goldstone, CEO RJR Nabiasco 2. Geoffrey Bible, CEO Philip Morris 3. Martin Broughton, Head of B. A. T. (parent company of Brown and Williamson) The Case The negotiation took place between the five largest tobacco companies of the United States, namely, Philip Morris, R. J. Reynolds, Brown and Williamson, U. S. Tobacco and Lorillard, and the Attorneys General of several states of America, where the later accused the former of burdening the taxpayer with costs of tobacco-related illnesses through the Medicaid Program, and for breaking the law by selling their product to children under the age of 18. The prosecution wished for the defense to: 1. Accept the responsibility of the illnesses and deaths caused due to the use of their product. 2. Pay a...

Words: 2252 - Pages: 10

The Case for, or Against, New Orleans

...The Case For, or Against, New Orleans Cost-Benefit Assessment Too asses and give recommendation on whether or not to rebuild the city of new Orleans I will be examining the cost to benefits of such a rebuild and the impact and benefits it will have towards the city. In the CBA, I will be examining the cost of rebuilding New Orleans to pre Katrina conditions without making any additional upgrades to the levees and infrastructure. This will give me a more accurate cost model to base my recommendation on. As for the benefits I will examine the benefits of recovered losses when comparing pre Katrina data to post Katrina dat. The areas where I will be examining are tourism recovered, port operations recovered, wages recovered, spending recovered, and taxes recovered. The future value (FV) of these benefits will then be discounted to present value (PV) and compared to the cost of rebuilding to represent the net present value (NPV) of the expected amount to be gained or lost by carrying out the recovery. If the NPV is less than the cost, then rebuilding New Orleans will yield a loss and my recommendation will not favor a recovery. If the inverse is true, and the proposal will be in favor of the recovery. All calculations will based on post Katrina 2006 reports and data to give a more realistic prediction of the decision that could have been concluded given data directly after the catastrophe. Costs of Rebuilding These cost are compiled from the Department of...

Words: 2219 - Pages: 9

The Case for, or Against New Orleans

... Jason Coleman 06-11-12 New Orleans Recommendation Paper The Case For, or Against, New Orleans Management Decision Models B6025 Dr. Usha Dasari We will look at many factors in our case for rebuilding or not rebuilding New Orleans. This recommendation will be reviewed by state and local governments for their decision. We will perform a Cost-Benefit Analysis which will represent the residents of New Orleans, the residents of the surrounding floods plains, the Mayor of New Orleans, and the federal government represented by FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) and the taxpayers. We will look at scenario models, risk management, and decision trees to support our decisions and analysis. This natural disaster took an enormous toll on the residents of New Orleans. Over 1200 lives were lost and countless injuries were suffered. The loss of revenue from the shutdown of businesses, loss of homes and possessions of residents caused much pain and human suffering. We will conclude with an executive summary which will summarize our decision for or against rebuilding of New Orleans. Prior to the hurricane New Orleans was a tourism magnet. The city offered many restaurants, festivals, and great weather. These positives made tourism a thriving market. Other boons for the economy of New Orleans were the mining, transportation, and warehousing along its waterways. More products came through this port than any other port in the world. There are many colleges in the area......

Words: 2509 - Pages: 11

The Case Against Tipping

...The case against Tipping Yes, but I have been on the serving side of the coffee house. Although most customers do not feel the need to tip the ‘coffee pourer’, doing so will most likely result in wonderful customer service. One downfall of having a tip cup next to the register is that most employers figure out the hourly rate while adding an estimated tip figure into it. A good thing about tipping the coffee pourer is you will always feel good about yourself knowing you let the worker know that you recognized them. Even though I feel tipping is a good part of showing recognition for good service, I do not feel that tipping is always necessary. In some cases, if a tip was mandatory, it could cost the same amount as the purchase. Although tipping could result in faster and better service, it does not always benefit the customers who do not have extra money to spare. Carnage as Entertainment Yes, but carnage as entertainment does not always have to be negative. Carnage as entertainment can very well cause a case against violence in the media by showing such entertainment desensitizes feelings against particular wrong doings. Carnage also makes a purpose to take action to push for the media with higher quality on the restrictions in viewing entertainment. It can also keep families occupied for hours. On the other hand, carnage may be proving to be a valid point against freedom of speech. It might go against what some see as a choice made consciously by those who watch it on......

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

The Case for and Against Drug Testing

...The dilemma of whether or not to have a drug-testing policy in corporate America is a colossal subject. Alcohol and drug abuse are considered to be amongst the most common health hazards in the workplace. Drug use in the workplace is an increased liability to employers and can cost companies millions of dollars. In this case study, a company named Castulon Corporation, is faced with a dilemma of whether or not to implement a drug-testing policy. The cause for this dilemma is the fact that upper management has been notified of two separate incidents in the past two months of possible drug abuse (Ivancevich, 2010). In this case study, I believe that the company should establish a drug-testing program. I believe that every company or business should have a drug-testing policy. There are many pros and cons to utilizing a drug-testing program but the biggest positive out ways everything which is safety. This is especially true for this case study as the company is in the manufacturing industry so they are at a higher risk for injury and loss of life (Ivancevich, 2010). A drug-testing policy would start with screening any newly hired employees. This would be a pre-condition of employment. The individual would have to pass an initial drug test. This pre-employment drug testing gives the employer a greater vote of confidence that they are hiring an individual that does not have a drug problem. To implement the drug-testing policy, the company must first provide the......

Words: 982 - Pages: 4