Charismatic Ceos and Succession Planning: Not so Charismatic

In: Business and Management

Submitted By geminiwin87
Words 3191
Pages 13
“Charismatic CEOs and Succession Planning: Not so Charismatic”
This article takes a look at CEO succession planning. It essentially focuses on charismatic CEOs and how they chose their successor. This article argues that the approach most charismatic CEOs take is flawed, hence, their successors tend to struggle. Most charismatic CEOs often do not make succession planning a priority until it is too late. In cases where a company puts a process in place, charismatic CEOs tend to be domineering in their choice of a successor. In other cases, charismatic CEOs die on the job, thereby making the transition shaky. Although this article delves into the open literature for insights, it also uses a case study to drive home the point that charismatic CEOs’ approach to succession planning is flawed.
The challenges of succession planning are truer today than ever. Indeed, the abrupt departures of two important charismatic CEOs – Charles Prince of Citygroup and Stanley O’Neal of Merrill Lynch – in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, which fetched these firms colossal losses have made scholars to beam their searchlight on this neglected aspect of corporate governance. The nonchalance with the way some CEOs handle the process of succession planning not only puts their companies in jeopardy, but also signposts a major criterion on which outgoing CEOs and their executive board members will be evaluated.
Before we proceed, we will issue a caveat: the practice of succession planning runs ahead of the theoretical understanding of the process. In fact, in the course of this research, we did not come across a single work on charismatic leaders. However, we did come across pockets of literature on CEOs and succession planning. It is from these literature and articles from reputable magazines like the Economist, Forbes and the Wall Street Journal that we extrapolated our…...

Similar Documents

Charismatic Theology

...Research Paper Of “A Select Issue in Contemporary Theology: Charismatic Theology." THEO 510-C03 LUO (Fall 2012) Survey of Christian Doctrine Dr. Eunice Abogunrin, Professor Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary Carol H. Montgomery (ID# 24993689) November 11, 2012 CONTENTS COVER PAGE 1 CONTENTS 2 THESIS 3 INTRODUCTION 3 CHARSMATIC GIFTS DEBATE 3-12 CONCLUSION 12 BIBLIOGRAPHY 13 INTRODUCTION This research paper will show that biblical referred to as glossolalia; the ability to “speak in tongues” is fiercely debated. While the Bible gives clear examples of genuine glossolalia, which will be examined later, the modern debate centers around the need or not, nature, importance, and usage of “tongues” today. Lastly, this paper will examine the biblical accounts of glossolalia along with more occurrences that are contemporary to determine whether modern episodes of “tongues” are needed or not needed. Out of all the gifts, the one that Paul speaks of the most controversial is the gift of tongues. "Glossolalia" is the most commonly accepted term for "speaking in tongues." It comes from the Greek words meaning "tongues" or "languages," and "to speak." Although not exclusively, "speaking in tongues" is primarily practiced by Pentecostal Christians. Glossolalia is the "prayer language" of Pentecostal churches. Some Christians who speak in tongues believe they are speaking in an existing language. Most believe they are uttering a......

Words: 3542 - Pages: 15

Xilinx Case - Charismatic Leadership

...[Xilinx] The variables that indicate charismatic leadership are described below, with an analysis of Wim Roelandts’ performance in each category. The case describes other instances of the Xilinx executives exhibiting some of the characteristics of charismatic leadership below but none of the examples mentioned incorporate as many of the variables as Wim Roelandts. The circumstances surrounding Wim Roelandts’ transition to Xilinx reflect many of the external factors generally perceived as characteristics of a charismatic leader. He came in from another successful firm, HP, with the goal of instituting visionary changes at Xilinx. He brought with him the idea that Xilinx could be both a firm which valued employees and treated them well while maintaining competitiveness in the market. Wim shares his vision of the company with the other managers as well as with the employees and motivates the members of the organization to work together to make the company a success and the workplace employee friendly. He maintains avenues of communication with employees even though it has become too difficult to speak with them in person. The employees make it clear that the emphasis on the value of their input and respect for their ideas is a key factor in their satisfaction despite other difficulties that might have engendered employee dissatisfaction. Charismatic leadership is an attribution based on follower perceptions of their leader’s behavior. Charismatic leaders… A.......

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6

Succession Planning

...Succession Management This year, Jim Pender, the President and CEO of Stonewall Industries, is set to retire after 40 years of service with the company. The executives from the new parent company, US Corp, have absolutely no idea who should replace Pender as President. All of the current VPs have various strengths and weaknesses and no one on the team seems to be viewed as the heir apparent. The internal candidates for the position would be VP Manufacturing, McBain; VP Mining, Khan; VP HR, Byer; VP Finance, Ho; and VP Marketing, Krajevski. Jones, VP of the Plastics Division is not viewed as a candidate because he doesn’t have gypsum wallboard experience. All of the candidates are viewed as ‘competent’ in their current roles. Byer and Ho are viewed as ‘exceptional’. Neither executive, however, has direct line management experience in the manufacture of gypsum wallboard. One of the key problems that the organization faces is that there is no formal performance management system in place, let alone a succession management process. Your group has been hired as consultants to US Corp with the mandate to: a. determine if there is a viable internal candidate for the President and CEO position within the Stonewall organization, and b. develop and implement a succession management process so that Stonewall will not find itself in this position again. Questions 1. Outline the major benefits of implementing a succession management process. (10 marks) -......

Words: 1942 - Pages: 8

Charismatic Leadership

...Charismatic Leadership Introduction We have evidence that charismatic leaders behave differently than non-charismatic leaders. Furthermore we know that charismatic leaders can generate social changes with ease, and that the performance of charismatic leaders and their subordinates is at a higher level when compared to that of non-charismatic. At this moment in time very little about the processes by which leaders and followers interact to effect social changes (Meindl, 1992). This paper will answer the questions I think need to be addressed when try to understand charismatic leaders: Why do charismatic leaders act and behave a certain way? Why do the people who follow react in predictable ways to these behaviors? How does the leader follower relationship and interaction generate social change? In this paper, we dissect certain behaviors that begin to explain why and how the charismatic leader-follower interaction can generate change in the workplace or in any social atmosphere for that matter. I will examine the speeches of some of out nation’s greatest and most charismatic presidents, the CEO’s of our country. The analyzing of these speeches will show that charismatic leaders use consistent communication techniques to break down, move, and then change the norms of their followers. Charismatic leaders have the ability to break down, move, and alter the mindset of their......

Words: 1436 - Pages: 6

Charismatic Leaders

...See Characteristics of a Charismatic Leader Charismatic leaders are known to attract followers and inspire people to new heights (Basu). Attracting followers and inspiring people takes a certain type of personality or certain characteristics. People just don’t follow any single person. Something draws people in and once in these people can be inspired to do things. Some people, like Charles Manson, drew in followers and inspired them to murder; while some people, like Gandhi, drew in followers and inspired them to be better people. (Rosenberg, Charles Manson) (Rosenberg, Gandhi-Biography of Mahatma Gandhi) Manson and Gandhi had certain characteristics that drew people to them in the first place. These may have included maturity, communication skills, humility, and substance. Other traits include not just leading but being liked, care for others before you care for yourself, celebrate life and inspire enthusiasm, see the best in people and channel it, deal in hope and spread the goodies (Alain, 2011). Charismatic leaders do not necessarily have all of these traits but these would be what to look for when choosing a charismatic leader. Charismatic leaders need to be mature. This does not refer to age. This maturity is a buildup of wisdom over years through experience. This wisdom can be in business it can be in whatever are the person excels. Manson new how to draw in women and used that knowledge to start a cult. Communication is a key characteristic. ......

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Obama Charismatic Leadership a time when the opportunity arose, but displayed refrain to keep the focus on the issue at hand. Throughout the evening, the president was precise in clarifying all misconceptions on health care reform. He did not have to defend himself from his stance on health care reform, but merely clarified all misconceptions and fabrications surrounding HR 3200. He did not have to resort to the “circle the wagons” mentality. President Obama displayed great optimism in believing that a bill, benefiting Americans, could be on his desk by the end of November. At every corner, and every transition in his speech, the president displayed brilliance. These traits are all traits that are associated with the Crisis Leadership Model. Charismatic Leader This charismatic leader has been criticized often for being a masterful communicator. During his campaign, Republican Minority Whip Leader Eric Cantor from Virginia, stated that “ to become the President of the United States we need to vote for a candidate who can do more than just make good speeches” (Cantor). This sentiment was echoed throughout the Republican ranks. The Chief Executive was indeed masterful in his speech. He was able to communicate his message effectively. His vision for this country was at times both direct and indirect. When the President of the United States said no one should be treated like that in the United States of America (Obama), he indirectly expressed to the audience his vision for the future of......

Words: 2026 - Pages: 9

Charismatic Leadership

...CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP: STRATEGIES FOR EFFECTING SOCIAL CHANGE C. Marlene Fiol University of Colorado - Denver Drew Harris Fairleigh Dickinson University Robert House University of Pennsylvania Second revision February 1999 Please address all correspondence to: C. Marlene Fiol University of Colorado at Denver College of Business CB 165 PO Box 173364 Denver CO 80217-3364 303-556-5812 CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP: STRATEGIES FOR EFFECTING SOCIAL CHANGE ABSTRACT Due to their unique relationship with followers, charismatic leaders can be powerful agents of social change. Current theories of charismatic leadership have emphasized primarily the personality and behavior of leaders and their effects on followers, organizations, and society. This emphasis fails to uncover why and how the charismatic leader-follower interaction can generate social change. Our study draws on theories of social meaning to develop a process model of charismatic leadership. Empirical exploration of our model suggests that charismatic leaders employ a set of consistent communication strategies for effecting social change. INTRODUCTION We have substantial evidence that charismatic leaders behave differently than non-charismatic leaders. Further, we know that charismatic leaders can generate radical social changes, and that the performance of charismatic leaders and their followers tends to exceed......

Words: 9711 - Pages: 39

Charismatic Leadership

...Different Types of Charismatic Leadership Krissy Island Liberty University Author Note Krissy Island, Student in Health Care Management with a minor in Human Resources at Liberty University. Abstract This paper will defines the different types of Charismatic leadership, whether it is used by a man or a woman. It will explore nine different articles to give a full broad view of how important charisma is when leadership is being obtained. The main charismatic leadership type that will try to be achieved is “Referent Power”. This paper will also go on to show how in business leadership is built and maintained. Also, how many famous leaders are prime examples of these charismatic leadership styles. It will go through the most powerful religious leaders, powerful business, and political powerhouses. This paper will show how each one possesses referent power and charismatic qualities and how they influence our decisions today. This paper will show how people use their charisma in daily day to day task and not even know they are using it. Keywords: Leadership, Charisma, Referent power Different Types of Charismatic Leadership There are different types of charismatic leadership. Charismatic leadership has cause some to debate over such a type of leadership. Some think it is difficult to define, such as Max Weber; he has also seriously tried to address the magical......

Words: 1692 - Pages: 7

Charismatic Leaders

...Charismatic Leadership 1 Running Header: Charismatic Leadership Charismatic Leadership Corie Roy Wilmington University April 2, 2012 Charismatic Leadership 2 In 1995, Business Review printed an article discussing charismatic leaders and those that are ethical versus the unethical in their standards. A study was conducted where 150 managers were interviewed on their leadership philosophy, which included their values, attitudes, personality characteristics, and leadership behaviors to categorize them as an ethical or unethical charismatic leader. Howell et. al. define an ethical leader as a charismatic leader who “incorporate their followers’ hopes, dreams and aspirations in their vision. These leaders develop creative, critical thinking in their followers, provide opportunities for them to develop, welcome positive and negative feedback, recognize the contributions of others, share information with followers and have moral standards that emphasize collective interests of the group, organization, or society. In contrast to the ethical leader, is the unethical charismatic leader, which is one who only cares about their own vision and what is best for them instead of the organization, nor their followers. To distinguish between the two types of leaders, key behaviors including, exercising power, organizational visions, communication with their followers, intellectually stimulating followers and developing the people they lead as well as the......

Words: 899 - Pages: 4

Succession of a Ceo

...Succession of a CEO: How Will ITT Educational Services Incorporated Succeed With Changing Their CEO? April Peck Daniel Webster College October 27, 2014 Executive Summary ITT Education Services, Inc. has been under a vast amount of scrutiny in the past year, not only from the media, but the government as well. How does a company like ITT Educational Services, Inc. overcome this scrutiny? With enacting a new CEO, what will that new CEO need to do in order to change the corporate culture and their strategy? Research that was conducted will show that there are other companies who have found themselves in a similar situation as ITT Educational Inc., as well as what they have begun to do in order to be successful in getting through these issues, while increasing how potential customers felt about the company. Along with this information, research was conducted to show what steps ITT Educational Inc. has already done in order to change their processes to become a more student focused company. In conclusion you will see that the research shows that while ITT Educational Inc. is in dire straits those steps that they have taken will assist with getting the company out of the hole they find themselves in now. Also, it will show that a new CEO can come into this company and with the right structure and strategy can take this company from where they are now to a company that has the ability to feel the same success they felt in early 2000, a while following the government......

Words: 2201 - Pages: 9

Charismatic Leadership

...Charismatic Leadership A charismatic leader is one who reveals “a transcendent mission or course of action that may not be in itself appealing to the potential followers, but which is acted on because the followers believe their leader is extraordinarily gifted” (Patrick, 2011, page 364). Charisma is the interplay between the leader’s traits and behaviors and the follower’s needs, beliefs, values, and perceptions. Charisma inspires devotion and enthusiasm. A charismatic leader is one who by their personality can have profound effects upon followers. The characteristics of a charismatic leader are a strong sense of self-confidence, conviction of the rightness of their own beliefs and ideas, and dominance (Patrick, 2011). Charismatic leaders are role-models who set the values and beliefs they want their followers to follow. They set high goals and demanding expectations, show confidence in their follower’s abilities, and articulate their visions of the future. The relationship between the leader and follower is emotional in nature and effects the follower’s commitment, motivation, and performance (Patrick, 2011). There are certain behaviors a charismatic leader exhibits. A charismatic leader sets the example for their followers. They model the value and beliefs they want followers to adopt. Charismatic leaders also build the image they want portrayed. They take actions that are viewed favorably by followers that provide an impression of competence and success. Lastly, goal......

Words: 472 - Pages: 2

Charismatic Leader

...Matt Charismatic Leader A charismatic leader is one of the modern leadership styles in the changing world. This kind of leadership pertains to Martin Luther King Jr, who used his charm to inspire and motivate people to unite against an unfair system that segregated and belittled a whole group of people. While Martin Luther King Jr. fits a number of different leadership styles, but I have chosen him as my charismatic leader because of his ability to; gain trust from his followers through visible self-sacrifice, the passion and conviction with which he spoke, and his ability to reach goals as a whole. He showed concern for the well-being of all types of people and genuinely cared for their needs. He demonstrated his skills as a leader in many different ways, a few of them being: he created a comfortable and approachable atmosphere with the people he came in contact, by listening to people and making them feel that they had voice in the decision-making process, and by standing firm against a mindset that other races could be inferior to others. When he spoke o crowds, he was able to appeal to many different types, for example: He used biblical references to appeal to the religious, he used his academic intellect to appeal to the scholarly, and he used specific inhumane events in his speeches to establish, that there was a problem and it was still going on here and now, to appeal to the human emotions. There is no question that Martin Luther King Jr. was a leader that possessed...

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

The Charismatic Gifts Debate

...9 THE CHARISMATIC GIFTS DEBATE PRESENTED TO PROFESSOR OGEDI OMENYINMA FOR THEO 350 – DO4 BY REV. JOSEPH T. WHITAKER, III LU23755920 LIBERTY UNIVERSITY LYNCHBURG VIRGINIA JULY 20, 2014 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------2 WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE SIGN GIFTS------------------------------------------------------ ARE THE SIGN GIFTS FOR TODAY OR HAVE THEY CEASED-------------------------------- ARE THE CONTEMPORARY SIGN GIFTS BEING PRACTICED BIBLICALLY-------------- CONCLUSION----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2 Introduction This charismatic gifts debate will explore God’s biblically stated purpose and intention for His supernatural gifts to be manifested in the practice of the New Testament Church. The question of whether the Bible declares if sign gifts are to be expected until the return of the Lord Jesus Christ, or have those gifts...

Words: 2988 - Pages: 12

Charismatic Leadership

...DATE: 12TH JUNE 2016 Charismatic Leadership Introduction Talking of charismatic leadership, scholars refer to the guidance provided to an organization by one or more individuals seen as heroic or inspiring and who have therefore been granted the organizational power to make dramatic changes and extract extraordinary performance levels from its staff. For example, a business manager imbued with charismatic leadership could be enlisted to orchestrate a turnaround or launch a new product line.Charisma is really a process – an interaction between the qualities of the charismatic leader, the followers and their needs and identification with the leader, and the situation that calls out for a charismatic leader, such as a need for change or a crisis. But when it comes to the charismatic qualities of leaders, the emphasis is on how they communicate to followers and whether they are able to gain followers’ trust, and influence and persuade them to follow. Most politicians, particularly on the national scene, have developed their ability to communicate effectively – to make speeches, “work the room” with potential donors and supporters, etc. So many seasoned politicians have a lot of “personal charisma.” This paper comes up with an essay providing a detailed analysis and discussion charismatic leadership, with respect to such fundamental aspects like characteristic of charismatic leaders, the merits and demerits of charismatic as a leadership approach, where it......

Words: 2378 - Pages: 10

Charismatic Theology

...The charismatic movement1 began within the historic churches in the 1950s. On the American scene it started to attract broad attention in 1960, with the national publicity given to the ministry of the Reverend Dennis Bennett, an Episcopalian in Van Nuys, California. Since then there has been a continuing growth of the movement within many of the mainline churches: first, such Protestant churches as Episcopal, Lutheran, and Presbyterian; second, the Roman Catholic (beginning in 1967); and third, the Greek Orthodox (beginning about 1971).2 by now the charismatic movement has become worldwide and has participants in many countries As one involved in the movement since 1965, I should like to set forth a brief profile of it.3 A profile of the charismatic movement within the historic churches would include at least the following elements: (1) the recovery of a liveliness and freshness in Christian faith; (2) a striking renewal of the community of believers as a fellowship of the Holy Spirit; (3) the manifestation of a wide range of "spiritual gifts," with parallels drawn from 1 Corinthians 12-14; (4) the experience of "baptism in the Holy Spirit," often accompanied by "tongues," as a radical spiritual renewal; (5) the reemergence of a spiritual unity that essentially transcends denominational barriers; (6) the rediscovery of a dynamic for bearing comprehensive witness to the Good News of Jesus Christ; and (7) the revitalization of the eschatological perspective. In one sense,......

Words: 2752 - Pages: 12