In: Business and Management

Submitted By pitt1k
Words 2136
Pages 9
Solyndra: Its technology and why it failed
Don Scansen, IP Research Group- November 22, 2011 inShare0 Save Follow
Save to My Library
Follow Comments
Follow Author
Solyndra was a darling of clean tech but filed for bankruptcy. Department of Energy loan guarantees of $535M sparked an investigation. No wrongdoing has yet been uncovered despite a huge waste of government money. Lower production costs in China have been singled out as the critical factor in Solyndra's demise. Will this story become a parable for America's waning competitiveness?

With its clever combination of solar and cylinder, the "O" with rays striking it, and the tag line, "The new shape of solar," marketing for Solyndra's unique tubular module design was at the top of the class. It is reminiscent of making oats cereal in small toroids, the shape of the letter O. We need to determine if there was more to Solyndra than just good public relations.

Figure 1: Solyndra's elegant design is evident in this 200 series panel with well-spaced cylindrical modules and simple mounting system.

Tubular module design
The design for Solyndra panels was based on a series of tubular modules mounted parallel to each other inside a frame. The generously spaced tube structure allowed airflow through the panel thereby reducing wind loading.

Where large-area flat panels might fly off a roof in strong winds, Solyndra claimed its panels could withstand 130-mph winds without specialized mounting. With no need to physically anchor the panel to the roof, Solyndra certainly delivered on the promise of simpler installation.

On the other hand, the danger of strong winds pulling flat panels off a roof is more of an issue for the partially upright mounts typical of panels angled to the optimum azimuth for the particular geographic location. As topical and "green" as solar panels are, they are a…...

Similar Documents

International Political Economics

...Election year is always a difficult time for those who expect politicians and pundits to remain rational. The political maneuvering started a while ago and clean energy became another point of contention between various political factions. “ONE YEAR AGO TODAY, THE SOLAR MANUFACTURER SOLYNDRA FILED FOR BANKRUPTCY AFTER RECEIVING A $527 MILLION LOAN GUARANTEE. THE BANKRUPTCY SET OFF A POLITICAL FIRESTORM IN CONGRESS, AND EVENTUALLY WORKED ITS WAY INTO THE PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN. TODAY, THE REPUBLICAN PARTY IS USING SOLYNDRA AS A KEY TOOL IN ITS CAMPAIGN AGAINST OBAMA — SMEARING THE ENTIRE CLEAN ENERGY INDUSTRY IN THE PROCESS.” (Lacey, 2012) Campaigns of this magnitude have a significant impact on the international political scene, and economic decisions. Considering that currently China has a very large and inexpensive manufacturing capabilities, as comparing to those in the U.S.; it should not come as a surprise that they can outperform Western (U.S.) manufactures. “PRICES OF SOLAR PANELS HAVE PLUMMETED, CAUSING A SUPPLY GLUT AND SLICING COMPANY REVENUES. SOLYNDRA'S COLLAPSE MARKED THE THIRD TIME IN AS MANY WEEKS THAT A SOLAR COMPANY DECLARED BANKRUPTCY. EVERGREEN SOLAR INC. OF MASSACHUSETTS AND SPECTRAWATT OF NEW YORK ALSO FILED FOR PROTECTION. (Mulkern, 2011). Clean energy is not only appealing to the United States, “THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT IS [also] INVESTING IN SOLAR PRODUCTION, WHICH HAS LED TO A BURST IN PRODUCTION THAT HAS BOOSTED SUPPLIES AND FORCED DOWN PRODUCT......

Words: 1911 - Pages: 8

To Drill or Not to Drill

...To Drill or Not to Drill Where does one stand on the political debate surrounding clean energy. What does America have to gain in a future free from foreign oil? Though the possibilities are endless, and the optimist in wants to believe that the country is headed in a green direction, I give pause to consider the circumstances. The promised growth of green jobs has come and, in the Bay Area, faded. In 2009, when Solyndra received $535 million in government loans to produce its manufacturing facility in Fremont, California, the Bay Area was ecstatic with the promise of new jobs and revenue. Fast forward to August, 2011, just one year after the plant construction was completed, Solyndra files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. All signs of life at the plant cease. There was nothing clean about millions of taxpayer dollars funding a project that lasted less than the warranty on a used car. Therefore, although I am leery of the government’s attitude in supporting the cause, I agree with President Barack Obama. Green energy is the way of the future and any sidestepping not only prohibits ingenuity and job growth, it burdens the environment. The key habit that colors my thought process is “mine is better.” Though I recognize that there are benefits to the use of fossil fuels, large amounts of energy can be created cheaply and transporting oil and gas to power stations is relatively easy, the facts outweigh the benefits. Fact is, offshore drilling produces toxic waste in the......

Words: 556 - Pages: 3


...Solyndra Solar Company Jennifer Bradley BUSN311 Saundra McDavid August 13, 2013 Solyndra Solar Company Solyndra Solar Power Company was founded in 2004, in Silicon Valley. This company had made plans to build solar panels without the use of polysilicon. However, these panels were going to be more costly to make but cheaper when it comes to installation. In 2005, Solyndra was offered to apply for a program through to government under an Energy Policy Act of 2005. Solyndra was granted this loan in 2009, with a total grant amount of $535 million and they were the first to receive the loan since the program had debuted in 2005. Solyndra’s problems began right after receiving the $535 million grant as they were already struggling financially. In August 2009, about two years after receiving the government energy grant, Solyndra files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Solyndra “will only be paying back about $24 million of $535 million loaned by the U.S. Government.” ("Solyndra Bankruptcy: Solar Panel Company Won't Pay Back Most Of Its $527 Million Government Loan ", 2012).This would mean bad news for the investors. After Solyndra filed bankruptcy, it caused them to lay off all of their workers which created even further legal issues for the company. Solyndra had to file bankruptcy due to the fact, production was becoming too expensive for them and the solar panel prices were increasing drastically. As a result from this, Chinese manufacturers were able......

Words: 1865 - Pages: 8


...likely that the credit is renewed beyond the sunset date, the temporary nature of various renewable energy policies invariably inhibits long-term investment planning by private sector businesses who are able to rely on the permanence of key oil and gas subsidies (Healey & Pfund, 2011). This analysis now turns to the role government policy can play in encouraging certainty and overcoming the risks associated with solar investment. IV. The Case for and Against Government Intervention The economic rationale for government subsidies of private industry is to spur investment in a public good that would not otherwise be produced or would not be produced at the optimal level for society. Specific to the loan guarantee program extended to Solyndra, the provision of public financing is argued to compensate for a dearth of private sector financing for solar energy research and development. By providing a government guarantee, risk adverse private financing may be encouraged to follow suit. However, those conclusions are not without disagreement. It can be argued that public sector investment in research and development can crowd out private sector financing that would otherwise materialize. The direction of funds through a government bureaucracy can be slow, and perhaps leaves venture capital decisions to bureaucrats ill-suited to differentiate between potential winners and losers. Moreover, loan guarantees may not be the most efficient government subsidy for the solar industry.......

Words: 2457 - Pages: 10

Solyndra Dr. Chris Granet, in the Fremont District of California, Solyndra is a company that deals in Solar Energy. Involved in the manufacturing process of Tubular Solar Panels, it’s an unrivalled player in this business. The company also offers a variety of other Solar Product options, as it’s been in the books of most solar manufacturing companies to use Flat panels which are traditional to Solyndra’s PV Solar System. Contrary to the Standardized solar panels as used in Ballast, the Solar Products manufactured by Solyndra are not entitled to be Standard specific. (David 2008). The manufacture and exercise of solar panel have a true ethical implication. There are issues wherein the admission to solar panel and the economic development has led to the distribution of resources that has affected the environment and also due to the usage of exhaustible resources with the purpose of certain kind of ethical values. As the Solyndra’s problem gradually started since 31st August 2011 onwards as the filling of legal plaintiff in the bankruptcy case (chapter 11). It had to receive the payment of more than half a billion which was basically a loan funding from the energy department of US after 2 years, $25.1 million dollars were also added which was generally tax exempt from the California’s Alternative Energy & Advance Transportation Authority (CAEATA), they were also given the permission to provide a helping hand to the Solyndra finance in the process of manufacturing of solar panel......

Words: 1460 - Pages: 6


...& Society MANA 4352.02 January 29, 2014 Topic: Solyndra Solyndra Scandal Solyndra designed, manufactured, and sold solar rooftop photovoltaic panels to commercial businesses, with the promise of “setting the new standard” for solar panels. Solyndra, formed in 2005, was an up and coming company who was on the verge of changing the way commercial businesses consumed energy. The system didn’t require any tools, and thus, would be four times faster to set up than any other panel. The issue with Solyndra from the start was that they didn’t have a steady fund. After financiers made several estimates, they came to the realization that Solyndra would be moneyless in a couple of years. In 2006, Solyndra applied for a government guaranteed loan, and just a couple of weeks before the company almost went bankrupt in 2009, Obama disregarded all red flags of this company’s viability and gave them $535 million in federal loan guarantees. Records, countless e-mails and advice given to President Obama by government staffers didn’t matter, because there had been signs of corruption all along the way. In July 2009, Solyndra founder, George Kaiser, gave a grant to a foundation close to Michelle Obama, who held a leadership post. The fact that the “Urban Health Initiative” foundation received $10,000 the same year Solyndra received their loan, adds to the pattern of possible connections between the Obama administration and the solyndra scandal. That same year, Steven Chu,......

Words: 458 - Pages: 2

The Anonymous Caller: Recognizing It’s a Fraud and Evaluating What to Do

...from error. The only concern I have about notifying the external auditor, is that if the external auditor discovered that the prior financial statement were also misstated, the caller could be punished for signing a bank commitment letter, when in fact the financial statement were misstated. Although fraudulently reporting financial statement is illegal, I think situation like the one presented in the case are very common accounting practices among companies. For example, according to the Bloomberg BusinessWeek News, Solyndra LLC, the solar-panel maker was under investigation for accounting fraud. Solyndra was submitting misstated financial statements to the Energy Department in order to receive government financing. Solyndra received more than $500 million as part of a stimulus package. However, in 2011 Solyndra filed for bankruptcy, and at this time the government learned that Solyndra was not as stable as they appeared in their financial statement. Solyndra had ballooned their inventory, specifically raw materials and went against the revenue recognition criteria, by inflating sales backlogs in order to continue receiving funds. Many senior executives who are under pressure to meet the company’s expectation, tend to negatively influence and force the accounting staff to perform unethical and illegal procedures. Imagine a senior executive is under pressure because the company has not met their earning expectation. The senior executive would then demand an employee......

Words: 2050 - Pages: 9


...Solyndra; The Problems, Legalities, & Ethical Frameworks Background Solyndra was a Fremont, California based manufacturer of cylindrical solar panels, founded in 2005. The solar panels that Solyndra manufactured could be used on top of flat rooftops, such as Target©, without needing additional land to set up the panels. (Grabell, 2012) Prior to any political and legal issues, Solyndra was well known globally and had hundreds of solar assemblies around the world. Solyndra had over $1 billion in private investments and over $2 billion in backlogged orders. (Grabell, 2012) Now, we fast forward to the American Recovery Act and Reinvestment Act of 2009, where Solyndra was granted a $535 million loan guarantee from the Department of Energy (DOE), to build a 300,000 square-foot factory near the existing manufacturing site, in an effort by the Obama Administration to go “green”, and create 1,000 jobs. The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA), is also known as the Stimulus Act. It was intended to save and create jobs and provide relief to programs like education, health, and renewable energy. Solyndra defaulted on the loan from the stimulus and eventually filed Chapter 11, Bankruptcy. After the Solyndra debacle, efforts to promote going “green” were considered scandalous. (Markham, 2013) Legal Troubles and Applicable Laws Many businesses and countries were all attempting the green efforts during the 2009 time period and China, specifically, was blamed for......

Words: 1988 - Pages: 8

Reflection Paper 3

...Daniel Atilla Helderman October 16, 2015 reflection paper 3: Shaping the future of solar power (Solyndra) After reading the case on “Shaping the future of solar power: climate change, industrial policy and free trade” I gained much clearer insight to the history and working of the solar energy industry. From personal experience, I have seen the recent increased use renewable energy, particularly wind and solar energy. Internationally, in Europe wind and solar energy as source of energy is not new revelation too me, many European countries, such as the Netherlands, my birthplace, are not new in utilizing wind and solar energies. What this case brought me to really learn was the involvement and the relationship of the U.S and China government in the solar energy industry. It came as no surprise to me that the U.S government was subsidizing the solar energy, however what came to light to me was the level of international competitiveness and political gridlock between China and the U.S in the solar energy industry. It was interesting to touch on the issue if governments should intervene in the market place. It became clear, that it was tough issue for the government to tackle, with one side of the government arguing that government intervention in the solar energy industry is hurtful and detrimental to business, highlighting the case of Solyndra bankruptcy. The other side, Obama administration, argues that the U.S needs to continue to subsidize and give tax break to......

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Solyndra Essay

...RUNNING HEAD: SOLYNDRA AND BAD BUSINESS DECISIONS 1 Solyndra and Bad Business Decisions Annette Frazer American Public University SOLYNDRA AND BAD BUSINESS DECISIONS 2 In 2005, President George Bush’s administration created a loan guarantee program to help fund and grow energy projects specifically. The program was overseen and decisions were made by the Department of Energy. The program was continued on during President Obama’s administration with very few changes. Under the Bush administration, Solyndra applied for and was denied financial assistance when they applied. Solyndra is a solar panel company that was issued more than $500 million in federally guaranteed loans during and by the Obama administration. (Report, 2015, p.1.) According to many, Due Diligence was not exercised by the Department of Energy in investigating this company and their request for funding. During the investigation, the people who were involved in investigating and eventually backing the loan stated that there was “political pressure” from the Administration to push through the loan. (Howell, 2015, p.1) It is speculated that one of the reasons that the loan was pushed through was that many of the investors of the company were major political contributors to President Obama’s campaign fund. This is would be considered a conflict of interest and could cause undue pressure to the loan investigators. Solyndra, however, also lied to the many agencies involved. They were not...

Words: 2219 - Pages: 9


...created is being followed per their standard. Controlling can be performed by all level of managers and in all type of concern. Controlling look to future and adjustment can be made whenever needed. According to Brech, “Controlling is a systematic exercise which is called as a process of checking actual performance against the standards or plans with a view to ensure adequate progress and also recording such experience as is gained as a contribution to possible future needs.” Conclusion Based on my personal experience above four functions are very important in all level of management. Following above functions can lead the Company to success, but not following them can close the company’s door forever. I’m a former Solyndra’s employee; Solyndra was a solar start-up Company. The Company was doing very well in beginning, but as it grew it fell a part because there was no proper planning, organizing, leading and controlling. Company’s goal was not clear to the employees and it was not being communicated very well. Also, there were lack of leadership and controlling; therefore the Company could not compete with others and filled chapter 11. In result 1100 employees lost their job. Reference Management study guide. (2008-2001). Retrieved from

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Project Paper

...Consumption component of GDP is the most stable considering steady positive growth while other component shows a positive and negative growth. b) Net exports as shown in the table registers the highest change (-4.52%) which makes it the most volatile as a percent of GDP? c) Ignoring net exports, investment component of GDP has grown the fastest as a percent of GDP since 1965. Exercise 1 2. Ethical Issues in Business In the article “Solyndra bankruptcy was disaster waiting to happen” by Martin La Moni stated that Solyndra is like other solar companies in that it could not keep pace with falling prices, despite having innovative technology. What sets it apart is that Solyndra secured a large $535 million loan guarantee from the Department of Energy to build a plant even though many industry analysts said that it faced an uphill battle competing on price. Overall, it raised about $1 billion from private and public sources. "In this case, questions have to be asked. The consensus view inside the solar industry is that Solyndra was not going to make it," said Shyam Mehta, a senior analyst at GTM Research. "The general idea of policy is fundamentally sound. What we have to do in the U.S. is make bets on innovative technologies that have the promise to lower costs. An article by Representative Paul Ryan published on September 22, 2011 in states “ But regardless of the potential legal impropriety, there is no question that the fundamental......

Words: 1259 - Pages: 6

Obama Advertisement

...As the 2012 Presidential Elections draw near the campaigns are now in full swing. In addition to the Republican primary race, Obama has begun campaigning and fundraising as well in an effort not to be out-done by his Republican opponents. In Michigan, Obama has recently launched his first TV commercial and also paid a visit to Ann Arbor to give a speech about his plans for 2012. Michigan is one of six states where Obama’s 30-second ad will play, according to the Detroit News. Beginning in mid-January, the ad entitled “Unprecedented” touts the President’s job creation, ending dependence on foreign oil, and expanding clean energy. In an attempt to deflect criticism over Solyndra and possibly ride the momentum from the Occupy Wall Street movement, the ad also says that “oil billionaire’s attacks on President Obama are not tethered to facts”, and claims that his record on ethics has been described as “unprecedented”. The commercial goes on to say that Obama created 2.7 million jobs through supporting and growing clean energy projects. It goes on to say that “for the first time in 13 years our dependence on foreign oil is under 50 percent”. It finishes by taking on a common attack on Obama, that he failed to fulfill his campaign promises, by saying that he tightened ethics in government. Interestingly, the ad came out around the time that the President denied permits for the Keystone XL pipeline, designed to carry Canadian oil to refineries on America’s Gulf Coast. ......

Words: 404 - Pages: 2


...their emissions faster than the cap decreases may trade their permits and make money. Firms that pollute beyond their quota must buy credits. To Europeans, Asians and Australians, this may seem nothing much. After all, the European Union already has a similar emissions-trading market, and a carbon tax is now wending its way through the Australian legislature. Even India and China have adopted versions of carbon taxes or emissions trading. But California is in America, which has taken a sharp turn in the opposite direction. Congress debated a cap-and-trade system in 2009, but then allowed it to die. Republicans attacked it as “cap-and-tax”, and increasingly deny that climate change is a problem at all. Some even point to the bankruptcy of Solyndra, a Californian maker of solar panels which had received lots of federal money, as proof that renewable energy is a wasteful pinko pipe-dream. There are similar versions of cap & trade systems already in places like Europe, Asia & Australia; America though has recently taken a sharp turn on environmental protection & also refused to acknowledge climate change as a problem at all, which could be because of some recent failures of companies in the renewable energy sector in USA. However, California is staying its course, besides cap-and-trade, its climate-change law calls for lower emissions from vehicles and cleaner appliances, and requires the state’s utilities to use renewable energy for one-third of the state’s electricity by......

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Ethics Paper

...that rely on the business for their needs. Solyndra overstepping ethical boundaries The Solyndra loan controversy is an alleged political controversy involving United States President Barack Obama. In 2009, the Obama administration reportedly authorized $535 million in loan guarantee to Solyndra Corporation as part of a program to promote alternative energy growth. This loan guarantee was originally focused on helping to create over 400 new jobs, but as time would tell, instead of creating new jobs, many were to be laid off. In October 2007, the Department of Energy had completed the review all of the applications and had narrowed the number to be considered. One of the 16 to be considered was the application from Solyndra. On January 9, 2009, the Department of Energy's credit committee "without prejudice" remanded the project "for further development of information. The decision was unanimous. They believed that there were several areas where the information did not thoroughly support a finding that the project was ready for approval. It was thought that the Obama administration wanted to rush federal reviewers to approve the loan so Vice President Joe Biden could announce it at a September 2009 groundbreaking for the company’s factory. The Federal Financing Bank, a part of the Department of the Treasury, loaned Solyndra the money on September 4, 2009. After receiving funds from the loan, Solyndra built a new manufacturing facility in......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5