Stock vs. Debt

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hhttz
Words 513
Pages 3
Stock vs. Debt
When forming a corporation, a transferor-shareholder should take into account some necessary factors to determine whether or not receiving some debt along with stock.
1. Tax Factors [ ① ]. For the shareholder
Firstly, to meet the requirement of section 351, the shareholder transferor must receive only stock. Although the gain under section 351 is deferred, if some debts are received along with stock, the debt will be treated as boot and gain will be recognized.
Secondly, for debt financing, the principle return is tax-free and the interest of the debt is taxed at an ordinary rate. However, for equity financing, the dividends are taxed at a preferential rate although they are double taxed (at entity level and individual level). In addition, a corporate shareholder has benefit from DRD.
Thirdly, when debts become worthless or result in losses on the sale, it does not qualify under section 1244. In that case, shareholders generally have capital loss rather than the ordinary loss for section 1244 stock. The capital loss generally can be offset only by capital gain while ordinary losses are deductible against ordinary income. [ ② ].For the corporation
Firstly, when issuing sock or debt, if we do not consider the benefit of shareholders, there are not significant differences for the corporation because issuing both stock and debt is not taxable. Moreover, additional money or properties received from shareholders through voluntary pro rata transfers are also tax-free even without issuing stock. Secondly, the big different tax treatments for the corporation exist after issuing stock or debt. The repayments of debt’s principle are tax-free and the interest of the debt is deductible by the corporation while the corporation should be taxed on its profit before it distributes dividends.
Thirdly, the thin capitalization problems give the IRS opportunity to…...

Similar Documents

Debt vs Equity

...Debt Versus Equity Financing Paper By Lori Houser ACC 400 Dr Debra Grimm Due September 10, 2012 There are several differences and similarities between leasing versus purchasing. What debt financing is, what equity financing is, and what alternative capital structure is more advantageous will be discussed. Leasing and purchasing can have many differences. Each has their places. Leasing offers 100percent financing, protection against obsolescence, less costly, and can avoid being added to debt on the balance sheet. Leasing allows you to have less money to start out with and not having to put out more money then you may have. Purchasing provides tax benefits, perceived financial advantages. Purchasing also requires having more money at the start. When purchasing you will have to have a bigger down payment then you would need to have if you were to lease. Purchasing may require the monthly payments to be bigger. Though both are different, they can in turn be the same as a company may have the option to purchase later instead of continuing to lease the property. Debt financing is borrowing money from an outside source that will be returned plus the interest agreed upon. Two examples of debt financing are gaining a line of credit from a bank. This gives a company the funds to make purchases. Another example is real estate. The company would need to find a lender that specializes in commercial lending. Equity financing is selling shares of stock in......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Fixed-Income Securities vs. Common Stock Securities

...ownership position in a publicly-traded corporation (stock), a creditor relationship with governmental body or a corporation (bond), or rights to ownership as represented by an option. A security is a fungible, negotiable financial instrument that represents some type of financial value. The company or entity that issues the security is known as the issuer” (Definition of ‘Security’). Typically securities are divided into equities that represent ownership interest that the shareholders in an organization hold and debt securities representing borrowed funds that must be paid back. In this essay I will be discussing the significance of understanding the differences between fixed income securities and common stock securities. In the United States, the sales of securities are regulated by organizations like the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority and the Securities and Exchange Commission or for short the SEC. Publicly traded companies have two classes of securities they issue, which are common stock securities and preferred stock securities. A security is what is considered a paper asset with the potential to be traded in small denominations (mostly) in the secondary market. Securities that pay a fixed amount of income are considered to be fixed-income securities i.e. bonds or preferred stocks. Bonds are debt securities that are dispensed by the government and corporations having a face value, or par. Unlike bonds preferred stocks are a representation of equal ownership......

Words: 567 - Pages: 3

Long Term Performance of Value vs. Growth Stocks:

...LONG TERM PERFORMANCE OF VALUE VS. GROWTH STOCKS: EVIDENCE FROM INTERNATIONAL MARKETS Zugang Liu, Pennsylvania State University Hazleton, USA Jia Wang, Rowan University, Glassboro, NJ, USA ABSTRACT This paper studies the long-term risk and return characteristics of value stocks versus growth stocks for three international markets: Asia, Scandinavia, and Europe. We focus on the downside of returns and use Value at Risk as our risk measure. We find that value stocks outperform growth stocks in terms of both risks and returns across all time horizons for all three markets. We further conduct cross country analysis. Interestingly, we find that there is some risk and return trade off in short term investment horizon across the three countries. When investment horizon lengthens, Scandinavian market has the best performance in both risks and returns for both value and growth indexes. Keywords: Value, Growth, Risk, Time Horizon 1. INTRODUCTION Value or growth? This is an age old debate in the investment world. Value style stock commonly refers to a stock that is undervalued relative to its fundamentals (i.e. dividends, earnings, sales, etc) and often has a low market to book ratio, a high dividend yield or a low P/E ratio. Growth style stocks are often shares from companies that are expected to grow at a higher than average rate and such stocks often have high market to book ratios, low dividend yields or high P/E ratios. Which one is more profitable? Basu (1977), among others,......

Words: 4356 - Pages: 18

Just in Time vs Stock

...JUST IN TIME vs. STOCK In a business is very important to manage and storage stock in an effectively way in order to maintain production and sales. To have an efficiently control of it, in this essay will we explained the advantages and disadvantages of having or not having stock and having the Just In Time method applied in your business. By stock we understand that is any item stored by a business for use in production or sales. There can be different types of stocks, one, raw materials and components which are the ones that are waiting to be used in the manufacturing process, number two, finished goods which are held in store so that a customer order can quickly be met from stock. To manage your stock successfully, you need to find a balance between the costs and benefits of holding stock. The costs of holding stock include the money you have spent buying the stock as well as storage and insurance. The benefits include having enough stock on hand to meet the demand of your customers. We have to be aware that having too much stock equals extra expense for you as it can lead to a shortfall in your cash flow and incur excess storage costs or that having too little stock equals lost income in the form of lost sales, but not just that, also undermining customer confidence in your ability to supply the products you claim to sell Holding stock incurs warehouse storage costs and ties up working capital. Funds must be found to pay for materials, components and unsold......

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Students vs. Debt

...Higher Education: Students vs. Debt Tuition rates in America are becoming more and more expensive and unaffordable for the average student. Universities keep raising rates every year, leaving students without a choice but to pay for the education they have already started. Financial aid offices give students a number when they are accepted to school, and this number indicates how much of your tuition tab the state will pick up. However, this number is subject to change every year, erasing all stability in a student’s expectations for post-grad debt. Not only are students graduating with enormous debt, the majority are either left without jobs, or working minimum wage jobs and barley able to make ends meet. Somehow, expert opinion still says that college is worth the overwhelming price of admission, but I say, that may not always be the case. Financial aid is supposed to be the governmental system to help families pay for higher education. The amount of money the financial aid office offers you is supposed to pick up whatever you and your family cannot afford. However, what they don’t tell you is that that amount varies year to year, and it is usually less then what they previously offered. “Can you imagine going to purchase a car and being told that the first year you will be paying $X. Next spring we'll tell you what you'll be paying for the next year and so on for the next four years” (Kastberg 1). According to some states, this is classified as unfair business......

Words: 1389 - Pages: 6

Debt Ratio

...liabilities. As of December 31, 2013 Starbucks current ratio is 1.273 vs. 1.847 on December 31, 2012. Current ratio determines whether a company will be able to meet their short-term obligations like paying their creditors and purchasing raw materials for its production and indicating the company’s efficiency. When a company’s current ratio is higher than a 2.0 it indicates that their current assets are larger than their short-term liabilities. When their current liabilities are greater than their current assets making the current ratio less than 1, the company may have trouble meeting their short-term debt obligations. Debt to equity ratio is determined by the long-term debt of a company divided by their shareholder’s equity. On December 31, 2013 Starbucks debt to equity was 0.419 vs. 0.1063 on December 31, 2012. Debt to equity ratio shows a percentage of the company’s assets that were financed by their debt vs. their equity. When companies have a high debt to equity ratio it shows that the company has strongly financed their activities through their debt and have to pay the accumulated interest on the financing which could result in volatile earnings. When there is a low debt to equity ratio it shows that the company have a lower risk due to the fact that the debt holders having less claim to the company’s assets. Return on equity ratio determines the rate of return on money that was invested from common stock owners which is kept by the company for previous years that......

Words: 428 - Pages: 2

Growth Stocks vs Vaue Stocks

...Iris Goode-Middleton MBA 570 Growth Stock and Value Stocks March 21, 2015 Purchasing stock makes investors part owners in the corporation. The stock purchased is an equity investment in the company. This makes the owner of the stock entitled to returns on their investment. When making stock investment decisions, there are two main stock types to consider investing in called value stocks and growth stocks. The goal of both stock types is to gain the best returns possible. However, they differ in characteristics. Value stock is defined as, a stock that tends to trade at a lower price relative to its fundamentals and thus considered undervalued by a value investor. Common characteristics of such stock include a high dividend yield, low price-to-book ratio and/or low price to earnings ratio (Investopedia, 2015, para. 1). Value stock investors are looking for stocks that are not reflecting their fundamental worth. The reasons for the stock being undervalued can be many. A company’s stock can be undervalue because it is experiences difficulties, its industry can be in decline or it can have a period of poor quarterly earnings. These are a few of the reasons why the stock can be undervalued. In general, value funds focus on perceived safety rather than growth, often investing in mature companies that are primarily using their earnings to pay dividends. As a result, value funds tend to produce more current income than growth funds...

Words: 1065 - Pages: 5

Equity vs Debt Financing

...Debt versus Equity Financing Debt versus Equity Financing Client Letter Accounting Associates 1425 Accounting Dr Chicago, IL 68572 April 18, 2015 John Doe, Chief Administrator XYZ Corporation 123 Somewhere St. Anywhere, USA 12345 Dear Mr. Doe: It was good to see you at the community fund raising event last Saturday afternoon. It is an honor to support this event for our community. In our meeting of February 16, you asked for guidance on the best possible approach in financing capital for your new corporation. There are two alternatives in financing, debt financing, which is borrowing from a lender and equity financing, which is selling of stocks to investors. It would be our recommendation as a start-up corporation to utilize both forms of financing to raise your capital while keeping debt financing to the minimum. In reaching this conclusion we considered the advantages and disadvantages, listed below, of debt financing versus equity financing. We reviewed the Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) approach on this matter and in consideration of code section 385 which is used to determine if the financing is debt or equity. The IRS may re-characterize debt financing to equity financing under this code section based on the circumstances of the financing (Antebi & Krauthamer, 2014). Advantages of Debt Financing | Disadvantages of Debt Financing | Interest paid is a deductible expense | Reduced cash flow due to monthly payment | Shareholders......

Words: 771 - Pages: 4

Reaction Paper: Stock Markets Fall on Fears Eurozone Debts May Spread

...Reaction Paper: STOCK MARKETS FALL ON FEARS EUROZONE DEBTS MAY SPREAD Greece, Portugal as well as the Republic of Ireland are in a mess. They are involved in the Greek crisis, as everybody calls it. The three countries are presently embracing their high debts and allegedly infecting other countries. The idea of contagion risk is gaining ground. With the three countries’ heap debts, Italy and Spain will likely go after. As a matter of fact, Italy's debt premium and Spain's borrowing costs rose to euro-era highs. At present, the third and fourth largest economies are experiencing downturns. Italy’s main Index decreased by 4% together with other markets such that on Asia and America. Finance Ministers came up with a strict budget and a € 48 billion cuts in Italy, which is expected to last by 2014, on their eight-hour meeting in Brussels. Further, they assured the public that enhanced measures will be taken to increase capacity resisting such contagion risk. This is with assistance of International Monetary Fund (IMF). A € 440 billion bail-out fund is intended for repurchasing current Greek’s debt, likewise is being considered for Italy and Spain. Investors, as a result, are getting more risk averse in doing their business. Consequently, yields on Italian Bonds are rising. With Greek crisis having no end, investors will continue such approach. Some of them, though, may take advantage and think otherwise. Euro currency being on its deathbed is not in question. “Together...

Words: 250 - Pages: 1

Stocks vs. Bonds

...Stocks Stocks are a form of ownership; they represent interest in a company's development. Typically, investors are given no guarantees about returns of the beginning venture. Truth be told, the productivity of the venture depends completely after rising stock cost, which, at the most key level, relates specifically to the execution and development (expanding benefits) of the company. Advantages of Investing in Stocks Stocks offer gainful returns back with constrained losses. When you put resources into stocks, you have the capability of profiting than you would with different types of investments, for example, fixed rate bonds and certificate of deposits, on the grounds that stocks participates specifically in the development of the economy and as time goes on have truly beat whatever other type of investment. However, any potential losses are constrained to the measure of your starting venture, not at all like different manifestations of investment that are utilized, for example, land where you could owe more than your original up front installment. In this respect, shareholders have constrained risk for the activities of the organization's administration in light of the fact that shareholders are detached investors that just participates in the capital gains and profits of the organization. Stocks additionally offer a lot of liquidity on the grounds that they can be sold at their market value and changed over to money whenever on the stock trade. Ultimately,......

Words: 1509 - Pages: 7

Value Stocks vs. Growth Stocks

...Growth Stocks vs. Value Stocks Thomas Anderton MBA 570 Professor Scott Growth stocks generally come from companies of high quality and who are considered successful. Investors expect the earnings of these companies to keep growing above the market average. If an investor were to analyze the companies with growth stock they would notice that these stocks have high price to earnings ratios and high price to book ratios. The price to earnings ratio shows the market price per share divided by the earnings. In order to have a high ratio generally the market price per share is high. Value stocks are the exact opposite of growth stock in terms of their price per earnings ratio and their price to book ratio, which means they generally have low ratios. These companies are generally expected by investors to increase in value when the rest of the market recognizes their potential. According to Bryan Rich of Forbes, “Value stocks are stocks with the lowest P/E, price to book, price to sales and price to cash flow. Other twists on value investing are simply looking at the lowest priced stocks in a major index or stocks with the highest dividend yield in a major index” (Rich, 2016). To some investors, growth stocks may seem to be expensive and at times overhauled, which could cause them to invest in value stocks. Investors may chase value stock because they don’t have as much money to invest as other investors who choose growth stocks. Some investors may choose to invest in growth...

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Debt vs Equity

...Debt versus Equity Financing Brenda L. Rochelle ACC/400 November 7, 2011 Carl Mir Debt versus Equity Financing Introduction In this paper, the author will attempt to compare and contrast lease versus purchase options by providing definitions of debt financing and equity financing and providing examples of each. Additionally, the author will attempt to address which alternative capital structure is more advantageous and why. Business owners must decide whether to purchase outright, finance purchases, or through a long-term lease. Full rights of ownership are realized when purchasing outright. Financed purchases lessen control of the asset by the buyer. Restrictions may be placed on the buyer’s right to sell by the lien holder in an installment purchase. In a long-term lease, the lessee lacks the right to sell, except for any purchase options available. An alternative is short-term leasing. This alternative frees the lessee of most risks of ownership, specifically obsolescence and maintenance. Additionally, the rental rate reflects these advantages. Choosing between outright purchase, financed purchase, long-term lease, and short-term leasing, causes management to face operational considerations such as maintenance, obsolescence, and the degree of control. Decisions involving financial considerations are necessary when ownership is selected. Debt Financing Debt financing is borrowed money a company receives in return for a promise to repay the loan. ......

Words: 515 - Pages: 3

Sovereign Debt Crisis - Greece vs. Argentina

...27.12.2011 Sovereign Debt Crisis - Greece vs. Argentina Everyday more and more headlines are being filled with the debt crisis in Europe. But the center stage of the developments in Europe is being taken away by Greece. As Greece is being basically bankrupt, its expenses are way bigger than its obligations; it is also being supported by the EU because of the fear of consequences from its collapse. Analyzing a Bloomberg article, about two economists, and their view of the Greece debt crisis, I found out that they tried to compare the “Greece crisis” with Argentina’s default in 2001. They argued about two lessons concerning how and what could Greece possibly go through. According to the article “the first lesson has to do with the timing and size of the debt exchange”. As I figured out it is about building up the solvency for the debt in way to get access to capital markets. First of all in the article it says that “Greece and its private creditors have been invited to implement a bond exchange with a nominal discount, or haircut, of 50 percent of face value”. This voluntary agreement they also call the default. So in order to do the right thing, the Greece attempt to extend the debt relief beyond the 50% haircut agreed upon, should be assessed by someone. Also it is argued that the faster Greece starts contributing solutions instead of delaying their problem they will be able to begin normalizing the relationship with capital markets. The second lesson as said in the......

Words: 1376 - Pages: 6


...------------------------------------------------- Debt A debt is an obligation owed by one party (the debtor) to a second party, the creditor; usually this refers to assets granted by the creditor to the debtor, but the term can also be used metaphorically to covermoral obligations and other interactions not based on economic value.[citation needed] A debt is created when a creditor agrees to lend a sum of assets to a debtor. Debt is usually granted with expected repayment; in modern society, in most cases, this includes repayment of the original sum, plus interest.[1] In finance, debt is a means of using anticipated future purchasing power in the present before it has actually been earned. Some companies and corporations use debt as a part of their overall corporate finance strategy. ------------------------------------------------- Debtor A debtor is an entity that owes a debt to another entity. The entity may be an individual, a firm, a government, a company or other legal person. The counterparty is called a creditor. When the counterparts of this debt arrangement is a bank, the debtor is more often referred to as a borrower. ------------------------------------------------- Accounts receivable Accounts receivable also known as Debtors, is money owed to a business by its clients (customers) and shown on its Balance Sheet as an asset.[1] It is one of a series ofaccounting transactions dealing with the billing of a customer for goods and services that the......

Words: 783 - Pages: 4

Debt Equity vs. Mutual Fund

...the advantages of investing in arch of these alternatives while dispensing with the shortcomings. Indian stock market is semi-efficient by nature and, is considered as one of the most respected stock markets, where information is quickly and widely disseminated, thereby allowing each security’s price to adjust rapidly in an unbiased manner to new information so that, it reflects the nearest investment value. And mainly after the introduction of electronic trading system, the information flow has become much faster. But sometimes, in developing countries like India, sentiments play major role in price movements, or say, fluctuations, where investors find it difficult to predict the future with certainty. Some of the events affect economy as a whole, while some events are sector specific. Even in one particular sector, some companies or major market player are more sensitive to the event. So, the new investors taking exposure in the market should be well aware about the maximum potential loss, i.e. Value at risk. It would be good to diversify one’s portfolio to include equity mutual funds and stocks. The benefit of diversification are that while risk exposure from a particular asset may not be very high, it would also give the opportunity of participating in the party in the equity markets- which may have just begun- in a relatively safe manner(than investing directly into stock markets). Mutual funds are one of the best options for investors to choose from. It must be realized......

Words: 9262 - Pages: 38